The events that led to the Battle of Burnt Corn Creek started in early July when Peter McQueen, another Chief who worked with Weatherford. Led a party of warriors down into Spanish controlled Florida where they could purchase gunpowder and shot with money given to them by the British. The Spanish gave this ammunition to his party for hunting purposes but continued to supply the Red Sticks whenever a new group would arrive. At this rate they would have enough ammo to fight in a matter of weeks. Once this became apparent to the militia stationed in Fort Mims they set out in an attempt to intercept McQueen before he could return with the ammunition.
Leading the American militia was colonel Jame Caller who had raised approximately 180 men. The set out East hoping to run into the Red Stick supply train returning from Florida. And on July 27th his scouts located McQueen's party camped along the Burnt Corn Creek completely unaware of callers militiamen. Seizing the opportunity Caller launched the attack. Caught off guard the Red sticks broke for the nearby trees in what appeared to the Americans to be a full blown rout. Believing they had won the Americans began looting the camp and taking the pack horses. But little did they know they Red Sticks quickly regrouped and were preparing to launch an attack of their own. Now on the other side of an ambush the preoccupied militia was scattered into the hills and would not regroup as easily. It took some members of the group two or three weeks to make it back to Fort Mims.
The final figures for the battle estimated 10 to 12 Red Sticks killed out of their 80 and only 2 militia killed out of a total of 180. Although the battle seems to be a victory by the Creek Red Sticks the Americans managed to grab or lose most of the ammunition the Creek were transporting.