The second floor gallery includes special rotating exhibits and a gallery dedicated to sports history and popular culture. The second floor also holds a gallery that continues the history of the early days of Crawfordsville with artifacts and photographs showing the growth of industry and local businesses, including photographs of retail establishments that have served local residents over the past century.
The establishment of the library can be traced back to several Crafordsville literary societies that operated throughout the second half of the 19th century. In 1897, local residents established the Public Library Association-an organization tasked with raising funds to build a public library building that reflected the community's growth. The movement gathered steam when the members secured a commitment from the Carnegie Foundation to offer $25,000 as a matching grant so long as the community could sustain the operation of the building and library. With many faculty and recent graduates of Wabash College leading the movement, the organization was able to reach its fundraising goal and became the first community in Indiana to build a library with the support of the Carnegie Foundation.