Inside, the house is a unique mashup of different styles and techniques. While Chick did not actually build the house with his own two hands, he certainly had more than a hand in the interior design and decoration. Downstairs, the house is somewhat in keeping with the Italian Renaissance exterior, with the rooms reflecting baroque splendor which, as with the exterior, is slightly less impressive on a closer viewing since Chick’s own attempts at painting and upholstery are a bit rough around the edges. Upstairs, he indulged in his secondary passion for modernism – in fact, the Osram lighting fixtures in the Bauhaus-inspired bathroom were to lend Chick his stage name. The dressing room he created for his wife Helen is considered to be one of the country’s first International Style interiors, with its black linoleum floor and walls painted each one in a different color.
While the Austin House may not have been to everyone’s taste aesthetically, it soon became quite the gathering spot for the Smart Set, a regular Who’s Who of midcentury artistic elite. No lesser lights than George Balanchine, Alexander Calder, Salvador Dali, Martha Graham, Agnes de Mille, and Gertrude Stein once sat down to dine on Chick’s home-cooked meals in his hand-decorated dining room, while composer Aaron Copland once sat and played the piano in the silk-panelled music room until 4 am. All this revelry continued until the early 1940s when WWII put a damper on everyone’s fun, and the party was definitely over by 1944 when Chick and the Atheneum came to a parting of the ways. Chick didn’t stick around Hartford much after that, returning to the nest only at Christmastime and then one final time in 1957 to die.
Helen Austin stayed on in the Hartford house even after her wandering spouse had moved on. She lived there up until 1985, at which time she, somewhat surprisingly, donated it to the very institution that had given her husband the boot some 40 years earlier. It might have given Chick a little posthumous satisfaction, however, to note that the Atheneum was subsequently stuck with nearly two years and half a million bucks worth of renovation work on the old place. The house and its interior had originally cost around $80,000, but most of the bills had been picked up by Chick’s indulgent mother.
Today, the Austin House remains one of Hartford’s more exclusive attractions. The house is only open for tours a few times a month and usually tours are limited to small groups and require a $25 per person donation.