Bill Twomey, a prominent Bronx historian, attributes the influx of German immigrants in the mid-19th century to the impact of the French Revolution of 1848, one of several revolutions on the European continent that reorganized society and displaced millions. The revolution in France was a factor directly linked to uprisings in the nearby German states and the massive German exodus to America. German immigrants were chiefly farmers, and as a result Melrose was an agricultural village in the mid-nineteenth century. German Catholic immigrants confronted rampant anti-Catholic sentiment throughout New York. Then-archbishop Hughes of Immaculate Conception was active in defending his congregation from a prejudice that often manifested in fires and violence. In this way, Immaculate Conception, from the beginning, has served as a safe haven for displaced and marginalized populations
More recently, the church’s devotion to support and provide security for its congregation has contributed to financial burdens and struggles. David Gonzales, in the New York Times article Steeple's Fall Leaves a Hole In Many Lives, writes about the tight budget for maintenance that resulted in the inability to replace the historic steeple. Maintenance is often a secondary budget priority as the church is frequently turned to by the people as not only “a place to worship, but also for help with things such as citizenship classes and preparing tax returns” (Gonzales). The steeple had become very much an unofficial landmark in Melrose, towering over the Hub that had become a home for the majority Latino and immigrant congregation. Gonzales interviewed Father McTighe, a church leader, on the inability to save the steeple. McTighe explained that “it’s the people, not a steeple, who make the church. This illustrates the church's dedication to the idea that it is defined not by its architecture and historic value, but rather by the people of its congregation (Gonzales).
Two years ago, Gonzales wrote another article highlighting the trend of financial burden and hardship for Immaculate Conception Church. Church leaders and congregation members, he reported, pushed back against the proposition from the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission to designate the church as a landmark. Such designation would require expensive repairs, argued the church's pastor Father Skelly, and it was struggling to afford basic maintenance and upkeep. Skelly, explained that funds for the church have frequently been dedicated instead to the congregation itself, while upkeep of the building is for maintenance, never fully for repair and renovation. As a majority immigrant community, the Church frequently helps with costs related to citizenship and taxes. Father Skelly is cited as saying that “the landmarks commission doesn’t care about people, they care about buildings. In contrast, Immaculate Conception has, from its founding to today, been a church devoted to its community.
Despite these financial burdens, the surrounding community is loyal to the Immaculate Conception Church. Sister Patrice Owens, who teaches at the church's school, was interviewed by students in a WHEDco-NYU partnership in spring 2017 and explained how the Immaculate Conception Church has been her biggest source of spiritual support. She discusses how the Bronx frequently gets a “bad rap” because of the criminal history connected to it, regarding gangs, drugs, and arson. However, this bad rap, she asserts, overlooks the people of the Bronx. She states how “they don’t look at the wonderful people that I feel surrounded by here in the Church.” She specifically points out church leaders, not only in the Immaculate Conception Church but in South Bronx churches as a whole, as individuals “who care so much about people, who care so much, who want to help them to improve the quality of their lives here.” In particular, she discusses the role of churches in improving schools.The significance of the Immaculate Conception lies not in its grand architecture nor the steeple, but in the diverse, devoted group of people who make up the congregation.
The history of the Immaculate Conception Church is very much a history of Melrose. The Church is a home and community within itself, and has been a haven for the people since its initial construction. The story of the Immaculate Conception Church is one of financial hardship stemming from displacement and immigration, but more significantly highlights the ways in which a community can unite to overcome struggle. The Church has dedicated its finances to its people rather than for historic splendor. Numerous accounts from members of its congregation express a level of admiration and loyalty to the Church that surpasses neighborhood boundaries and relocation. The Immaculate Conception Church becomes a root people take with them through moves and times of displacement, and contributes to the notion of Melrose as a safe haven for immigrants and newcomers.