From there, the story gets a bit murky. One story has it that Phelps had the lumber brought from Maine, since there were no sawmills in the city at that time. The other, and perhaps more plausible, story is that Phelps bought the home in New Orleans and had it shipped in sections around the Horn to California. According to that version of the house's history, Augusta Roussell Phelps, who was Southern, was so homesick that her husband had the house brought from New Orleans to remind her of home.
There may be no way to know for certain how the house came to be in San Francisco, but there is no question that elements of its design are unmistakably Southern. Many Southern homes were built--as is the Phelps home--on a high foundation to allow air to circulate underneath. The house's veranda is also a characteristically Southern touch.
Nowadays the home is privately owned and is not available for tours. It was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1979.