During its tenure, the aviary was reported to display Seven cages containing monkeys, one with at least a half dozen healthy alligators, one with cockatoos, one with Australian doves, one with parrots and one with canaries. However, interest in exotic animals waned. The aviary was re-purposed into a branch library for Lynchburg's Department of Parks and Recreation in 1971.
In 1975, it was leased to the Lynchburg Council of Garden Clubs, and they maintain it today. It is currently used as a garden center and wedding venue. The Aviary was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1980.