Originally designed as the parsonage for the Mars Hill Baptist Church, which at the time was located in what is now Owen Theatre, the Jarrett House has been owned by Mars Hill University since 1953. Named in honor of R.F. Jarrett of Sylva, North Carolina, the Jarrett House served a variety of purposes for campus before it was torn down to make room for campus imporvements.
Built sometime between 1918 and 1921, the former Jarrett House was
originally designed as the parsonage for the Mars Hill Baptist Church,
which at the time was located in what is now Owen Theatre. Located on
land given to the church by I.B. Shive and his wife, it is not known
whether the same architect Martin Egbert Parmalee, who designed Owen for
the church, designed the parsonage. Reverend Jesse R. Owen was the
first pastor to reside in the house and continued to do so until his
resignation in 1931. Following Owen’s resignation, at least four more
pastors of the Mars Hill Baptist Church lived in the building.
With a new church building in the works, Mars Hill Baptist agreed to
sell the church building and the parsonage to Mars Hill College in 1953.
The college repurposed the building as faculty housing and renamed it
the Jarrett House in honor of R.F. Jarrett of Sylva, North Carolina, who
donated funding in the 1940s for faculty apartment housing that would
never be built. By the 1990s the Jarrett House was repurposed once more
as the office for Mars Hill College campus security. Campus security
remained in the building until 2004 when it was given to the theater
arts department. In 2006 the Jarret House was one of several buildings
designated as part of the Mars Hill College Historic District by the
National Park Service and was listed on the National Register of
Historic Places. The Jarrett House was demolished in 2013 to make room
for Day Hall, which is built on the site of this historic structure.