Calvin Fletcher Historic Marker
Front side of historic marker
Back side of marker
House built in 1895 for Fletcher's grandson, Calvin I. Fletcher (III), in Indianapolis
Bust of Calvin Fletcher that is found in the Indiana State House
1856 daguerreotype of Calvin and Keziah Fletcher
Circa 1840s-1860s photo of Fletcher. Courtesy of Indiana Historical Society.
Sketch of Calvin Fletcher from "Greater Indianapolis," 1910, Chicago, by Jacob Piatt Dunn.
Backstory and Context
Fletcher was born on February 4, 1798, in Ludlow, Vermont, the eleventh child of Jesse and Lucy Keyes Fletcher's fifteen children. Fletcher’s father, a poor man with a large family to support, still managed to provide his children with a basic education. Young Fletcher attended local schools until the age of sixteen and worked on the family farm. With his father’s permission, Fletcher left home in 1815 at the age of seventeen. Fletcher went to Windsor on the Connecticut River, where he worked on several local farms before moving to Royalton and later to Randolph, Vermont, to attend school and work. Fletcher returned home for a brief time then moved to Westford, Massachusetts, to attend school.
In 1817, after completing his education at Westford, Fletcher once again set out on his own. With no particular destination in mind, Fletcher traveled south through Connecticut to New York City and Philadelphia, then west through Pennsylvania to Wheeling. Fletcher ended up in Urbana, Ohio, in 1817, where he taught school, studied law under James Cooley, and was admitted to the Ohio bar in 1820.
Fletcher married Sara Hill on May 1, 1821, in Urbana and they moved to Indianapolis, Indiana, in 1821. Arriving in the small settlement nearly penniless, Fletcher became a wealthy lawyer, banker, and landowner. Calvin and Sara had eleven children: two daughters (Maria and Lucy) and nine sons (James Cooley, Elijah T., Calvin Jr., Miles J., Stoughton A., Ingram, William B., Stephen Keyes, and Albert. His eldest son, James Cooley Fletcher, became a Presbyterian minister and missionary. Sarah Hill Fletcher died on September 27, 1854.
On November 4, 1855, Fletcher married Keziah Price Lister from Hallowell, Maine, who had come to Indianapolis in 1851 to become a public school teacher. Lister, whose first husband had deserted her and moved to Texas, obtained a divorce and then married Fletcher. In 1855 Fletcher moved his children and second wife into the Alfred Harrison home on North Pennsylvania Street in Indianapolis, leaving the Wood Lawn house to his son, Miles, and his family.
Fletcher began his law practice in Urbana, Ohio, and was the first attorney practicing law in Indianapolis. He was a prosecuting attorney for the Marion County Circuit Court in 1822 and 1823 and a prosecuting attorney for the Fifth Circuit Court in 1825 and 1826. Fletcher went on to join a law firm with Ovid Butler, Simon Yandes, and Horatio C. Newcomb. On December 26, 1846, Fletcher and Butler dissolved their law practice and collection business, but Fletcher continued to devote time to his farming operations and banking interests.
In 1825 he was elected state senator and remained in office until his resignation in 1833. This was the only political office Fletcher ever held. Fletcher was a member of the state Sinking Fund Commission from 1834 to 1841. He was affiliated with the anti-Jackson and Whig parties. As a member of the Free Soil party, Fletcher was a member of the party’s state committee and served as its convention chairman in 1849. In the 1850s Fletcher was a member of the Fusion party1 and then became active in promoting the Republican Party ticket in the 1856 state and national elections. In 1860 Fletcher supported the Republicans in state elections and Abraham Lincoln’s presidential election.
In 1844 Fletcher helped organize the State Bank of Indiana, where he acted as the Indianapolis branch's director from 1841 to 1844 and as branch president from 1843 to 1858. He remained active in banking for the rest of his life. In 1857 Fletcher was an organizer of the Indianapolis Branch Banking Company. In 1863 he joined his son, Stoughton, his brother, Stoughton, and fellow bankers Thomas H. Sharpe and Francis M. Churchman in organizing the Indianapolis National Bank, which was the second national bank in Indianapolis.
Fletcher was a stockholder in the Indianapolis and Bellefontaine Railroad (later called the Indianapolis, Pittsburgh and Cleveland Railroad) as well as a board member, and served briefly as its board president in 1855. Shortly before his death, Fletcher made a public appearance in support of a proposed Indianapolis-Vincennes railroad.
From 1839 to 1855 Calvin Fletcher owned a 269-acre farm called Wood Lawn in the early settlement of what would become known as Fletcher Place. After Fletcher sold his part of the farm at Wood Lawn, his son, Stoughton, divided it into lots and developed into a residential area. The settlement had several residents who made "many contributions were made to the early development of architecture, religion, commerce, education, and social life in the city of early Indianapolis." By 1852 Fletcher’s farms adjacent to Indianapolis’s northeast side increased to approximately 1,400-acre. He also owned other farms in Marion County and in Morgan County, Indiana.
Fletcher was active in community service. Although Fletcher’s own education was limited, he was a strong supporter of a free public school system. In 1851 Fletcher was appointed to the Southeast District as one of three superintendents for the new Indianapolis free public schools. In 1853 the Indianapolis City Council appointed Fletcher as one of the first members of the Indianapolis Board of School Trustees. Fletcher was also appointed a trustee during the organization of Asbury College which became DePauw University, serving on the college’s board from 1837 to 1839 and as its treasurer from 1848 to 1855. Fletcher was also a trustee for the Marion County Seminary and the Indiana Female College.
Fletcher supported agricultural development and helped organize Indiana’s first agricultural fairs in the county and state. In addition, Fletcher was a founder of the State Horticultural Society. He also helped to found the Marion County Agricultural Society and was elected its president in 1851.
Fletcher was an abolitionist like his friend and colleague, Ovid Butler. In 1852 Fletcher’s long-standing interest in colonization led him to support a State Board of Colonization that would provide state funds to assist Blacks living in Indiana to establish a colony in Africa. In addition, Fletcher and his family contributed to and participated in the American Civil War. Three of Fletcher’s sons served in the Union army. He also supported the organization of the U.S. colored troops in Indiana during the war and the 28th Regiment U.S. Colored Troops used his farm land to train between December 1863 and April 1864. During the war, Fletcher helped provide aid for soldiers’ families, assisted local efforts to welcome returning soldiers home, and served on the city’s Sanitation Committee. At the request of Indiana governor Oliver P. Morton, Fletcher purchased arms for Indiana’s regiments. After the war, Fletcher contributed to the Freedman’s Aid Society.
Fletcher assisted the Indianapolis Benevolent Society, a local organization that helped the city’s poor, serving for years as its secretary. He was also interested in the efforts of the Widows and Orphans Society and active in the temperance movement.
Fletcher was known as a very religious man. He joined the Methodist Church in 1829 and provided financial support to assist other denominations build their own churches. Fletcher served as superintendent of Sunday Schools at Asbury Chapel and Roberts Chapel, helped establish these Methodist congregations in Indianapolis, and also attended Wesley Chapel on the Circle. He contributed to the erection of almost all the early churches in Indianapolis. The Fletcher Place United Methodist Church was built on the on a portion of the farm, after the land had been donated to the church. Fletcher helped acquire property to establish Crown Hill Cemetery, a new burial ground at Indianapolis, and organized the nonprofit corporation to operate it.
Fletcher had a longtime interest in history. He was a member of the New England Historical and Genealogical Society and one of the original members of the Indiana Historical Society, founded in 1830. Fletcher's diary, donated to the IHS by his family in the 1920s, is in the IHS collections and provides “a powerful contribution” to understanding life in “the early nineteenth-century Midwest.
Fletcher died on May 26, 1866, after a brief illness and complications from injuries he suffered when he was thrown from his horse two months earlier. Fletcher was buried at Crown Hill Cemetery in Indianapolis. Keziah Fletcher sold the Fletcher home on Pennsylvania Street after her husband’s death, left Indianapolis, and returned to the East Coast, where she died in Boston on June 10, 1899. Several of the Fletcher children went on to have successful careers of their own.
A marble bust of Calvin Fletcher is on display in the Indiana Statehouse.
Brand, Carl Fremont. "The History of the Know Nothing Party In Indiana" (Article). Indiana Magazine of History Indiana Magazine of History, Volume 18, Issue 1. pp. 47–81. Retrieved 15 April 2016. In Indiana as elsewhere there was a movement for a Fusion or People's party. The Know Nothings, perhaps the strongest of all the elements of the opposition but not strong enough to run a ticket of their own, determined to act with the Fusionists, to control the whole movement and to direct it in their own interests
https://scholarworks.iu.edu/journals/index.php/imh/article/view/6056/5832 The Origin and Rise of the Republican Party in Indiana from 1854 to 1860 Title: The Origin and Rise of the Republican Party in Indiana from 1854 to 1860 Author: Charles Zimmerman Date: 1917 Source: Indiana Magazine of History, Volume 13, Issue 3, pp 211-269 Article Type: Article
Geib, George, "The Diary of Calvin Fletcher and the Historians," Traces of Indiana and Midwestern History 10(1):22.
Thornbrough, Gayle, ed., The Diary of Calvin Fletcher (Indianapolis: Indiana Historical Society, 1972) 1:xii.
Thornbrough, Gayle, ed., The Diary of Calvin Fletcher (Indianapolis: Indiana Historical Society, 1973) 2:xiv
Thornbrough, Gayle and Riker, Dorothy, eds., The Diary of Calvin Fletcher (Indianapolis: Indiana Historical Society, 1974) 3:ix.
Thornbrough, Gayle, Riker, Dorothy, and Corpuz, Paula, eds., The Diary of Calvin Fletcher (Indianapolis: Indiana Historical Society, 1975) 4:xii.
Thornbrough, Gayle, Riker, Dorothy, and Corpuz, Paula, eds., The Diary of Calvin Fletcher (Indianapolis: Indiana Historical Society, 1977) 5:xx.
Thornbrough, Gayle, Riker, Dorothy and Corpuz, Paula, eds., The Diary of Calvin Fletcher (Indianapolis: Indiana Historical Society, 1978) 6:xxi.
Thornbrough, Gayle, Riker, Dorothy and Corpuz, Paula, eds., The Diary of Calvin Fletcher (Indianapolis: Indiana Historical Society, 1980) 7:xii.
Thornbrough, Gayle and Corpuz, Paula, eds., The Diary of Calvin Fletcher (Indianapolis: Indiana Historical Society, 1981) 8:xiii–xiv.
Ruegamer, Lana, A History of the Indiana Historical Society: 1830–1980 (Indianapolis: Indiana Historical Society, 1980) p. 60.