Designed by Thomas A. Mullet, the Gibson-Todd House was built in the Late Victorian style, with a conical tower and two-and-a-half floors. While the house has history behind it, the site it is built upon is much more well known as the execution site of John Brown. Following the demolition of the old Jefferson County jailhouse, Gibson used stones from the jail to construct a monument on the property to commemorate the event.
The house was inherited by Frances Prakette, Gibson's granddaughter, and her spouse Augustine J. Todd. Prakette would donate the building to the the National Trust for Historic Preservation. It would be added to the National Register of Historical Places in 1983.