Wyandots captured Wetzel and his brother from their home when Wetzel was 13, but they managed to escape and return back to Wheeling after two days of being held captive. The boys were taken while tending the family farmstead, and Wetzel recieved gunshot wounds during the attack and resistance. After this incident, he perfected shooting a long rifle and fighting with a tomahawk and a knife. He was rumored to have been able to shoot anything that was big enough to see, and could skillfully load, prime, and shoot a long rifle while running full speed through the woods. Wetzel, his father, and brothers were among the defenders of Fort Henry when it was attacked by British and Indian forces in September 1782.
Wetzel was known as an Indian hunter. He never took up land, built a cabin, farmed, or did 'normal work'. He roamed across Ohio country hunting Indians and carrying out one man raids. He proclaimed a one man war on the Indians after his father and brothers were killed by Indians during a hunting trip. As the years passed, people began to question his sanity. He wore tassels in his split earlobes and took great care of his almost, knee length hair. Wetzel's Cave is where he would lure Indians so he could kill them. The following is the legend of Lewis Wetzel's Cave:
In 1788, Lewis Wetzel made one of his occasional visits to Wheeling where he visited his sisters in Fort Henry. He soon learned of a turkey-call which had been plaguing everyone so much because it had been heard many times and many places, thus giving the call a supernatural quality. Men had tried to find the source of the plaintive sound frequently never returned. After hearing many different stories, Wetzel left the Fort in search of the mysterious bird. Night fell as he searched the hills, so needing a good vantage point, he climbed to the fork of a tree. The mournful cries soon came at intervals and at times seemed to be very close and then far off in the distance. In the light of the moon he saw something pass silently through the brush up toward the top of the hill. At dawn he descended from the tree and found some faint marks in the brush which led him sixty feet above the creek on the east side of Creek Hill where the trail ended suddenly. Here he found the mouth of a capacious cavern, running he knew not how far underground, the entrance almost completely obscured by a heavy growth of vines and foliage, He hid in the brush and late in the afternoon a piercing turkey-call broke the silnence. The cries came from the cavern! Wetzel saw an Indian slowly rise in the mouth of the cave and, Then, twisting his mouth into a long horn-like shape, the red-skin sent forth the shrill, prolonged, and peculiarly distressing, moaning cry,... Wetzel raised his rifle and aimed carefully at the warrior's head. He pulled the trigger and ended the turkey-cry forever.1
Wetzel's most well know murder is that of Seneca chief Tegunteh, who was peacefully involved in the negotiation of the Treaty of Fort Harmar. Wetzel was arrested twice for this crime, but was never punished. He claims to have taken 27 scalps, but there is reason to believe that the count could have been higher. After the Treaty of Greenville, Wetzel moved to the Louisiana Territory, where he was arrested and convicted for counterfeit. Wetzel died in 1808 in the Mississippi Territory, but was buried near Wheeling. Wetzel County, West Virginia is named after this infamous killer.