The game itself was played between the Knickerbockers and the New York Club. The game only lasted 4 innings, with the NY Club winning 23-1. During the game, Alexander Cartwright was the umpire; he ended up fining a few players for cursing. By the 1950s, seven National Association of Base Ball Player teams were using Elysian fields as their home field; this included the Knickerbockers, the NY Mutuals, and the NY Metropolitans.
The year 1873 was the last recorded game at Elysian Fields. The field was turned into a housing development afterward. The intersection between 11th Street and Washington Street is believed to be where the diamond would've been. In fact, there is an intersection in the area that marks where all four bases should have been. Adjacent to where third base was, sits a restaurant/music club called Maxwell's. A bronze plague emphasizing the fields importance is placed on the median strip of 11th street, which would have been between first and second base.