The team remained one of the premier African American teams for nearly 20 years and defeated many other African American teams leading to the title of World Colored Champions in 1887 and 1888. The success of the team spawned imitators as well as nearly a century of premiere black teams using the name Cuban as part of their name as part of their effort to attract white fans who might otherwise not enjoy watching talented local black athletes.
The famous Argyle Hotel in Babylon was one of many luxury hotels constructed in the late 19th century to accommodate wealthy summer visitors from New York City. It was constructed in 1882 by August Belmont, a resort entrepreneur, and built upon the former estate of Brooklyn railroad magnate Electus B. Litchfield. Financing was provided by a syndicate headed by Long Island Rail Road President, Austin Corbin.
The grounds of the hotel included a large millpond, Blythebourne Lake, which was renamed Argyle Lake as a tribute to one of the hotel’s largest investors and town aristocrat, the heir to the Dukedom of Argyll. The renaming gave the Hotel & Park a more genteel English flavor yet the hotel proved a bad venture: it was near the end of the era of such projects, it was built much too large with 350 rooms, and so was rarely more than one-third filled. After about a decade of disuse, it was finally demolished in 1904, some of the structure being used to build homes west of the lake in the neighborhood now known as Argyle Park.
In 1921, the land that is now the Argyle Park was donated for passive recreation to the Village of Babylon, by J. Stanley Foster,Esq. This park is still popular, drawing substantial numbers of visitors from outside the community for fishing, strolling, playing on the children's playground, and winter ice skating. This hotel and its employees are largely responsible for integration in sports and giving people like Jackie Robinson a place to play.