The new American Theater had seats for up to 1000 viewers. Each seat was built from mahogany and Spanish leather. The lobby area had marble tile and was decorated in ivory, gold, and green. A gradual incline led to the balcony area, which was carpeted in green velour.
Moviegoers could take advantage of the nursery, smoking room, and coat check room. The theater operated with two Powers 6B projection machines. The heating, ventilation, and lighting cost $10,000, which included dim lighting for a screen presentation. There was also a stage which was used for live presentations with a backstage dressing room for performers. Mr. Eiler arranged for the purchase of a $25,000 organ from the American Photoplayer Company. The organ was used in the orchestra pit, which was in front of the screen. Mr. Eiler later sold the theater to Yakyma exhibiter Fredrick Mercy in 1926. Today, the building is used by Macy's Department Store. The sloped incline still remains, as well as the theater seats.