The Cavalier Hotel has hosted numerous famous guests throughout its lifespan, including Presidents Calvin Coolidge, Herbert Hoover, Franklin Roosevelt, Harry S. Truman, Dwight Eisenhower, John F. Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, and Jimmy Carter. Other pop culture guests at the Cavalier include Muhammad Ali, Bette Davis, Judy Garland, Doris Day, F. Scott Fitzgerald, and Frank Sinatra. Since reopening in 2018, numerous contemporary celebrities have been guests of the hotel, including Kim Kardashian and Kanye West, Missy Elliott, Pharrell Williams, P Diddy, Gwen Stefani, Pusha T, and Dave Matthews.
In October of 1942, the United States Navy converted the hotel into a radar training facility. During World War II, the hotel provided living quarters to so many sailors that they were even required to live in the stables.
In 1973, after the sister hotel, The Cavalier Oceanfront, opened, the original hotel was closed for three years. It reopened in 1976 and was closed again in 2012. Renovations began two years later in 2014.
During the recent renovation, many historically important architectural elements have been restored to their original elegance. The Sunken Garden still remains on the south side of the hotel featuring Jeffersonian inspired walls and brick. The iconic hill that the hotel perches upon still stands out, especially with the addition of the word Cavalier” embedded in the landscape overlooking Atlantic Avenue. The lobby or “Rotunda’s” historic stairs and iron railings remain a focal point. All existing original floors, exterior cast stonework, and interior moldings, as well as certain windows and doors in the public spaces, were all meticulously restored. The indoor pool, originally called “The Plunge,” had saltwater pumped into it straight from the Atlantic Ocean. By 2012, the pool had deteriorated to the point where water had to be pumped into it at all times to keep it filled. While many of the hotel’s renovations saved the hotel’s original character, the pool had to be entirely redone and was a major project. The Hunt Room fireplace was disassembled and repaired. The process involved removing and numbering each individual brick, allowing them to be replaced in their exact position. The total cost of the renovations amounted to $81 million, and the Cavalier Hotel reopened in March 2018.
Since opening, the Pocahontas Room, now home to the restaurant Becca, remains one of the hotel’s most iconic features. This room continues to be used as a formal dining hall. On the opposite side of the Pocahontas Room is the Raleigh Room. Unlike the Pocahontas room, the Raleigh room has its original floor, as well as historic beams and walls.
One major change to the landscape of the Cavalier is the boom of homes in the surrounding area. A portion of the money from home sales was used in paying for the hotel’s renovations.