There were two major bare knuckle fights that took place at Collier's Station, the first was the 1873 Lightweight Championship between Harry Hicken and Bryan Campbell. The fight was rough before and after it began. Both sides had a hard to agreeing to a referee, which delayed the fight and caused the crowd to get rather rowdy as they threatened to cut the rings ropes. The fight would last for 24 rounds when both fighters fell down, and both sides start crying for fowls. A fight erupts from both sides corners, which ends up dragging the crowd into the fight and a running fight takes place. The fight is given a winner, but Hicken would be declared the winner soon after.
The second major fight took place in 1880 and was the World Heavyweight Championship between Paddy Ryan and Joe Goss. This fight didn't turn into a full brawl like the previous title match held at Collier's Station, but it was an impressive fight to say the least. The fight lasted for an outstanding, and terribly long for the fighters, 87 rounds. Ryan, over the course of those 87 rounds, had taken an incredible beating from Goss, especially to the head. It was stated that his entire body was covered in bruises from Goss's fist. Despite all of that though, Ryan would go on to win the match because of Goss's age, which caused him to not be able to continue after the 87th round. Goss would get his revenge though when Ryan would fight John Sullivan later to defend his championship, which he would lose to Sullivan.