Anne opened her doors to the New York literati community at her literary meetings almost as soon as she unpacked her bags. It was here that her soirees became most influential and coveted, with names like Edgar Allen Poe, Margaret Fuller, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Walt Whitman, and Herman Melville often frequenting her parlor every Saturday night. The Literary News journal recalled in 1894, She received every Saturday evening. American literature was just beginning to make itself felt, and her house became the weekly gathering place for aspiring poets, writers, and novelists.
It was here that Edgar Allen Poe first presented The Raven, reciting it before the crowd that had gathered that Saturday night. At this time, Poe was a regular at the Lynch house, but when flirty correspondence was brought to light between him and Fanny Osgood, another Saturday night regular, Anne kicked him out of the social circle. The correspondence was a huge scandal, as both parties were married. Anne's reaction reflects the deep devotion she held towards preserving the purpose of the literary circle, discussions that focused primarily on literature instead of scandal.
Today, 116 Waverly Place is little more than an expensive, upscale New York apartment. There are no visible markers which designate the house as one that once hosted the most prestigious literary names in American history, but such a history is there to be found for those who seek it out.