The historic home saw its first massive renovation at the turn of the twentieth century by Natt Augustus Reynolds, a younger son of the late Daniel. Drawing on themes of the Colonial Revival era, Natt Reynolds added sweeping verandahs, as well as expanding the kitchen and topping the home with a third story.1 One of the most impressive attributes of the home is its dozen fireplaces.
While the mansion remained in the Reynolds family until the 1960s, it uses varied from generation to generation. Not long after this first renovation, Natt died, and the remaining Reynolds women operated the mansion as a rooming house, foreshadowing its distant conversion into what in known today as The Reynolds Mansion Bed and Breakfast Inn. In the 1920s, Elizabeth Smith capitalized on Asheville's growing reputation as a health destination and rented the mansion from the Reynolds family in order to open an osteopathic sanitarium.
It wasn't until 1970 when the mansion finally made it into the hands of Fred and Helen Faber, the founders of the modern day Bed and Breakfast. By this time, the mansion was in neglected disrepair. The Fabers undertook the daunting project of fully restoring the home themselves, recreating its nineteenth-century charm and making as few additional renovations as possible. While the demands of a bed and breakfast required certain architectural modifications, such as the addition of bathrooms for guests, the main features of the home remained unaltered. Their work was rewarded in 1984 when the Reynolds mansion was inducted into the National Register of Historic Places.