Harry Floyd’s refusal of service and the frustration of the students came to a culmination on February 6, 1968 when a group of African American students from the aforementioned colleges went to the bowling alley and refused to leave. The following day, another group of students did the same thing and were met by officers who threatened to blast them with water from fire hoses. The students refused to back down and police officers responded by beating the students with billy clubs. Fifteen people were arrested.
On February 8, over 300 African American students showed up at the All Star Bowling Lanes and refused to leave. They were met there by over 100 local, county, and state law enforcement officials. The students were beaten badly when they tried to enter the building. This violent event played a major role in the Orangeburg Massacre which took place on the campus of South Carolina State College.
On the evening of February 8, 1968 students gathered on the campus of South Carolina State College to protest the racial segregation of the bowling alley and other privately owned businesses. After an officer claimed to have heard a gunshot, the some 70 police officers and National Guardsman opened fire on the crowd wounding as many as 28 and killing three students. Nine officers were charged with shooting at the protesters, but all were acquitted. Due to simultaneous events and the Vietnam war, national media coverage was limited and local media outlets spread misinformation and blamed the victims of Orangeburg Massacre.
The former All Star Bowling Lanes became the All Star Triangle Bowl and was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1996. In 2007, the bowling alley closed due to financial difficulties.