The Fargo family legacy is filled with influence in the development of Lake Mills from a pioneer town to a thriving Village as well as controversy and grievance of untimely deaths from illness and the multiple marriages of Mr. Fargo.
The home's featured a ballroom on the third floor, turrets, wrap around porches and covered carriage entrance. The manicured lawns and gardens contained at one time a tennis court and a bear pit where two pet black bears were kept until their assisted escape one Halloween night by some local youths and a ladder caused Mr. Fargo to donate them to a zoo in Milwaukee.
The home also had an unusual shared feature with the neighboring residence owned by E.J.'s brother Frank. The homes were connected by a tunnel accessible in the cellars.
Mr. Fargo's business interests ranged from raising dairy cattle to the manufacturing of dairy equipment with his Creamery Package Company, to holding interest in the Bank of Lake Mills and hotel ownership/management of the Rock Lake Hotel on West Lake Street.
E. J. Fargo married three times; his first wife Mary died from illness but not until after they lost Mertie, second daughter of three, to a contagious disease she contracted by picking up a doll from a burn pile at another home where another child had died and the contaminated items were to be burned to prevent the spread of the disease. E. J. remarried a much younger woman who was only a few years older than his oldest daughter Elsie. Addie the second wife was a well educated socialite who was active in many clubs and supported the literacy pursuits for women. Addie's sudden death and quick burial at the age of 29 from what was reported as diphtheria, left many people questioning what really happened. E.J.'s youngest daughter Mattie (Martha) was to graduate the same day that Addie was buried from the Lake Mills High School. E. J. quickly remarried to Martha who had been a servant at the mansion within months of Addie's death. Martha out lived E.J. and sold the home to Clarence Wendt. in 1946.
When the mansion was saved from demotion by Tom Boycks and Barry Luce in 1992 they quickly began restoring the mansion, replacing the architectural elements that had been salvaged and registering the house on the National and State Historic Place Registries. Today the house is still in the process of being restored, however the majority of the rooms have been updated and serve the Bed and Breakfast guests, who also enjoy the expansive porches, grand dining room and stair case. The tunnel, bear pit and original carriage house no longer exist, however the grand home still anchors the historic neighborhood on Mulberry Street.