In 1919, the city almost lost the school. In December of that year, a fire broke out within and despite the efforts of firefighters and faculty members, the interior was just about completely gutted. As the building was being rebuilt, classes and graduation commencement ceremonies in two nearby churches. The cost to rebuild exceeded insurance costs, but the insurance company willfully made an adjustment to help in the rebuilding. The school reopened in 1920. The uniqueness of this building made it a feature on Ripley's Believe it or Not!
Three decades later, the city continued to grow and soon, over 800 students attended the school, but the building was not made to serve such a population. A new high school was made in 1959 and all the students went there, leaving the old school empty. Since then, this building still serves the city and county. It is now home to the county library and offices to county school superintendents.