In 1887, Goodnight did not renew his contract with Cornelia Adair and established his Goodnight Ranch in Armstrong and Donley counties, where he moved the herd of bison and later conducted his famous cattalo experiments. Probably in early 1888, colonel and Mrs. Goodnight constructed the home where they resided until the mid-1920’s. Records show that he hired a carpenter for $100 a month to travel to Louisiana to select cypress wood for the house, which became the first home in the new town of Goodnight, Texas.
During the next four decades, the Goodnight Buffalo Ranch became a nationally-known destination for scientists as well as tourists and the Goodnights entertained thousands of people in their home. In 1916, Colonel Goodnight filmed on the ranch a silent movie, Old Texas, that included several Comanche Indians chasing and killing a bison cow and butchering it while thousands of spectators watched.
In 1919, the Goodnights sold the house and ranch with the provision that they could live there for the rest of their lives, if they wished. Mrs. Goodnight died in April, 1926. Colonel Goodnight lived in the house until the end of 1926 when he moved to Clarendon, but many of his and Mary Ann Dyer Goodnight’s possessions remained in the house when he died in December 1929 and many of these items have survived in the hands of various family members and institutions.
In 2005, Mr. and Mrs. Brent Caviness and Mr. and Mrs. Marsh Pitman donated the home and 30 acres of land and an initial investment toward preservation. Since that time, a $3 million plus campaign has been underway to restore the homestead and furnishings, build a visitor’s center, and raise an operations endowment. Realizing that this project has a broad appeal to all Texans, the Texas Historical Foundation’s Board of Directors chose the Goodnight House Restoration as their project for the year 2007. The Goodnight House is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and is designated as an America’s Treasure.
In an article about the Goodnights published about 1931 by the Amarillo Daily News, Phebe K. Warner, the wife of a Claude physician and a well-known writer, wrote, “We couldn’t erect a monument to their (Charles and Mary Ann Goodnight’s) memory equal to their value to our country. But there is one thing we can do. We can preserve the monument they builded for themselves which would be more honor to us and more joy to them if they knew about it now. And that would be to preserve their home and their beloved buffalo for the pleasure of all the people.
“The greatest desire of their declining years was to know that their home with all its memories and attractions which they had created around it would be perpetuated as a living, growing, self-supporting monument, not to themselves alone, but to the Panhandle pioneer men and women who lived their lives for the development of the Panhandle. Will the people of the Panhandle forget? Will they neglect...forsake such a heritage?”