Corwin quickly climbed the ladder of the elite in Salem, working as a shipbuilder, merchant, and importer of British goods. In 1662, Corwin’s younger sister Abigail married into the Hathorne family. Both Jonathan Corwin and John Hathorne served as judges during the examinations of the witch trials and decided whether a citizen was guilty of practicing witchcraft.
According to the book Death in Salem: The Private Lives Behind the 1692 Witch Hunt, Corwin sometimes used the eastern front room of this house to conduct interview and interrogations. Although twenty were executed and many in Salem acknowledged their role in the hysteria, there is no evidence that Corwin expressed remorse for his involvement in the witch trials of 1692. Corwin died in 1718 is buried at Broad Street cemetery in Salem, MA.
In the 1940s, the city of Salem wished to enlarge North Street. This would have resulted in the demolition of the Corwin house. However, Salem citizens raised $42,000 and saved this house, along with the neighboring Bowditch House. The house now stands approximately 35 feet back from its original location. The home was later restored by historic Salem in 1946 and opened as a museum two years later.