The amount of new followers became too much for the small chapel. Expansion of the church was needed. This led to the development of a new church in Ogden Avenue which is the current church. This new church is a one story sized building made of gneiss ashlar and has a large bell tower built onto it. The building also has a steeply-pitched gable and three round-arched windows with voussoirs, connected to the tower by a tourelle, and both side elevations have buttresses and round-arched windows with leaded stained glass.
As mentioned beforehand, there were actually two churches built. One was built in 1866 and the other built in 1888. The one built in 1888 was built by the firm of D.C. Works and Son and was constructed to the design of Alfred E. Barlow. It was built in the Richardsonian Romanesque style. This style is named after Henry Hobson Richardson, a famous American architect. The style is regarded as an informal suburban style by critics.
Unfortunately, the Union Reformed Church of Highbridgeville disbanded in 2005. Later, in 2006, the Highbridge Community Church was founded by the Fordham Manor Reformed Church. Pastors Irving Rivera and Cora W. Taitt from Fordham Manor Reformed Church came together with many others to reestablish the church. The HighBridge Community Church believes in spreading the teachings of God and behaving in ways that promote respect to other people. The pastor of this church is currently Cora W. Taitt.